Oct 30, 2020
This week, xeolabs released
xeokit-sdk 1.4.8 and
xeokit-gltf-to-xkt 0.5.0, which
allow us to accurately view BIM models at their original IFC global coordinate locations within xeokit's
browser-based viewer, without rounding errors. In this post, we'll describe the problem this update solves, and how
to upgrade your xeokit application to use this update.
Sometimes, xeokit users would report that certain models would "jitter" as they moved.
The screen capture below shows the problem, using a model of the Marc Antoine Petit apartment complex in Lyon, provided by BIMData. The IFC geometry for this model is in IFC global coordinates. Notice the way the model "shivers" as we rotate it.
Figure 1. Rounding Jitter on WebGL
[Run this example]
After some investigation, it turned out that:
The models had geometry that relied on double-precision values. This was either because the
models were geographically
large with fine details, or because their geometries were positioned far from the origin of the IFC
global coordinate system
(BIMData's model happens to be positioned at
[1842022, 10, -5173301], which is
somewhere in Lyon, France).
WebGL can only support single-precision values to ~7 decimal places of accuracy. Using graphics APIs such as WebGL, OpenGL and Direct3D, graphics processing units (GPUs) internally operate on single precision 32-bit floating-point numbers. Therefore, the jittering turned out to be rounding error within WebGL shaders, as each vertex position continually snapped to its nearest available single-precision value.
So far, we've managed to avoid rounding jitter by using certain
scripts on IfcOpenShell, to "center"
the geometries within our IFC models (see: Creating
Files for Offline BIM). These workarounds work by transforming the geometries from IFC global
coordinates to IFC local coordinates, which are (hopefully) small enough to be accurately represented by
The problem with these workarounds is that we lose the original global placement of our models. This means that we cannot load multiple models belonging to the same site and have them positioned correctly with respect to each other. Instead, they would all be in their local IFC coordinate system, and once loaded into xeokit, would be positioned right on top of each other.
Furthermore, if the model is geographically huge, with fine details (eg. a 10km long roadworks that relies on 1cm accuracy), then centering doesn't help anyway, because the geometry will still have huge coordinate values.
The solution was to extend
xeokit-gltf-to-xkt with the
ability to emulate double-precision geometry rendering on WebGL, as a robust way to eliminate rounding
jitter with IFC models that contain
large geometry coordinates.
The screen capture below shows how this solution completely eliminates rounding jitter with BIMData's
without needing to convert it to IFC local coordinates. Within xeokit's viewer, the model actually
retains its full IFC global
coordinate precision, and is still centered at
[1842022, 10, -5173301] (somewhere Lyon, France).
Figure 2. double-Precision Emulation in xeokit
[Run this example]
We can even load a second model, with IFC global coordinates centered at, say.
xeokit would happily have both of these models in the viewer, situated
away from each other.
Our jitter elimination uses a technique known as relative-to-center (RTC) geometry coordinates, which is used in flight simulators and geospatial visualization applications to accurately render very large models on single-precision GPUs. We won't describe the RTC technique here, but you can read all about it in the book 3D Engine Design for Virtual Globes, which was a valuable resource during the development of this release.
We'll now describe how to upgrade your xeokit application to work with double-precision models. You can also find more information in the GitHub pull request for this update.
First, update your version of
that you're using that within your model conversion pipeline to convert glTF models to xeokit's
.XKT native geometry format.
Then add the new
-f 6 option when you invoke
executable. This will cause the executable to output the new
.XKT 6 format, which preserves
double model precision, using the RTC technique mentioned earlier.
$ ./gltf2xkt -f 6 -s scene.gltf -o scene.xkt
If you're using
IfcConvert with option
to center your models to avoid rounding jitter, then you can now remove that option.
Likewise, if you're using
IfcOpenShell scripts to center your models
to avoid jitter, you can now remove those script invocations from your conversion pipeline.
Lastly, update your version of
later. This version is
a backwardly-compatible drop-in replacement for 1.4.7, which does not emulate double-precision.
Now you can convert double-precision IFC models to
.xkt 6 and load them into your xeokit
application, to accurately view them in the browser.
As mentioned, pull request #456 has info on what code has been updated in xeokit-sdk 1.4.8.
For improved maintenance and QA, the converter logic in
xeokit-gltf-to-xkt, used for
.XKT 6 format, has been
factored out into its own library,
xeokit-convert. This allows us to more easily document and unit test the
converter logic, and to more clearly use it as a reference implementation for developers wanting
to build their own
tools to generate
.XKT 6 format. Take a look at that library's repository for more
.XKT 6 and RTC.